Why Did My Bread Fail? 12 Common Bread Baking Problems Solved

🤔

Every Baker Has Been There

Bread baking is one of the most rewarding skills you can learn — but the learning curve involves a lot of "what went wrong?" moments. Every problem has a cause, and every cause has a fix. This guide covers the 12 most common bread failures, explains why they happen, and shows you exactly how to prevent them next time.

1. My Bread Didn't Rise

🔍 The dough stayed flat and dense, not doubling in volume.

Cause 1: Dead yeast. If you used active dry yeast, it may have been expired or killed by water that was too hot (above 50°C kills yeast instantly).

Cause 2: Room was too cold. Yeast is sluggish below 20°C and nearly dormant below 15°C.

Cause 3: Salt was placed directly on top of yeast, which can kill it.

✅ Fix: Always proof your yeast first — dissolve in warm water (38–43°C) with a pinch of sugar, wait 5–10 minutes for foam. If no foam, the yeast is dead. Keep dough in a warm spot (24–28°C). Mix salt into flour before adding yeast.

2. Dense, Heavy Crumb

🔍 The bread rose but slicing reveals a tight, heavy interior without holes.

Cause 1: Under-kneading. Gluten wasn't developed enough to trap gas bubbles.

Cause 2: Under-proofing. The dough wasn't given enough time to rise fully.

Cause 3: Too much flour. A common mistake — measuring by volume instead of weight can add 20–30% extra flour.

✅ Fix: Knead until you can stretch the dough thin enough to see light through it without tearing (the "windowpane test"). Let the dough rise until truly doubled. Always weigh ingredients with a kitchen scale.

3. Bread Collapsed After Rising

🔍 The dough rose beautifully, then deflated in the oven or when touched.

Cause: Over-proofing. The yeast consumed all available sugars and the gluten structure stretched beyond its limit. The gas bubbles become too large and fragile, and collapse under their own weight.

✅ Fix: Use the poke test — press the dough gently with a floured finger. If the indentation springs back slowly but not fully, it's ready. If it doesn't spring back at all, it's over-proofed. Reduce proofing time by 15–20 minutes next time.

4. Pale, Soft Crust

🔍 The bread is cooked through but the crust is blonde and lacks crunch.

Cause 1: Oven temperature too low. Most bread needs at least 220°C.

Cause 2: No steam in the oven (for lean breads). Steam keeps the crust pliable during the first 10 minutes, allowing maximum rise, then the dry heat creates the brown crust.

✅ Fix: Preheat oven for at least 20 minutes. Use a Dutch oven (traps steam automatically) or place a cast-iron pan on the bottom rack and pour in 1 cup of hot water when you put the bread in. For enriched breads, use an egg wash for colour.

5. Crust Too Thick or Hard

🔍 The crust is so thick and hard that it's difficult to slice or chew.

Cause 1: Over-baking — the bread was in the oven too long.

Cause 2: No moisture in the dough — low hydration produces thicker crusts.

✅ Fix: Use a probe thermometer — bread is done at 88–96°C internal temperature depending on type. For a softer crust, brush with melted butter immediately after removing from the oven, and cover with a clean towel while cooling.

6. Gummy/Wet Interior

🔍 The outside looks done but the inside is sticky and under-baked.

Cause 1: Sliced too early. Bread continues cooking via carryover heat for 15–30 minutes after leaving the oven. Cutting early releases steam and stops this process.

Cause 2: Under-baked. The crust browned before the interior finished.

✅ Fix: Always wait at least 30 minutes before slicing (1 hour for large loaves). Use internal temperature to judge doneness, not colour. If the top is browning too fast, tent with foil and extend baking time.

7. Bread Has Large Holes on Top, Dense at Bottom

🔍 Uneven crumb — a few huge caverns near the crust with dense, tight crumb below.

Cause: Improper shaping. Air pockets were trapped under the surface during shaping, while the interior wasn't given enough structure to develop evenly.

✅ Fix: When shaping, gently degassing and folding creates even tension. Don't just roll the dough into a ball — create surface tension by pulling the dough toward you on an unfloured surface, tucking the edges underneath.

8. Bread Tastes Bland

🔍 The texture is fine but the flavour is flat and uninteresting.

Cause 1: Not enough salt. Salt is not optional in bread — it controls fermentation and amplifies flavour. Most bread needs 2% salt relative to flour weight.

Cause 2: Short fermentation. Quick rises produce less flavour than slow, cold fermentations.

✅ Fix: Use 2% salt (10g per 500g flour). For more flavour, try an overnight cold fermentation in the refrigerator — the slow yeast activity produces organic acids that give bread depth and complexity.

9. Bread Stales Within Hours

🔍 The bread was great fresh but became dry and crumbly within a day.

Cause: Starch retrogradation — the starch molecules re-crystallise as the bread cools, pushing water out. Lean breads (flour, water, salt, yeast only) stale fastest. Enriched breads with fat, sugar, and eggs stale more slowly because those ingredients interfere with crystallisation.

✅ Fix: Add 1–2 tbsp of olive oil or butter to lean doughs for longer shelf life. Store in a paper bag at room temperature (not the fridge — refrigeration speed up staling). Toast day-old bread to refresh it. Freeze for long-term storage.

10. Crust Separates from Crumb

🔍 A large gap between the crust and the interior, like the bread has a hollow shell.

Cause: Under-proofing combined with high oven temperature. The exterior set and browned while the interior was still expanding. The interior eventually pulled away from the rigid crust.

✅ Fix: Proof longer until the dough passes the poke test. If you suspect under-proofing, reduce initial oven temperature by 10°C so the crust sets more slowly.

11. Sticky Dough That Won't Come Together

🔍 The dough sticks to everything and seems impossibly wet.

Cause 1: Recipe is correct and this is normal. Many artisan bread doughs are deliberately high-hydration (75–85%) and are meant to be sticky.

Cause 2: Too much water. Using volume measurements instead of weight, or different flour brands with different absorption rates.

✅ Fix: Wet your hands instead of adding flour — water prevents sticking without adding extra flour. Use the stretch-and-fold technique instead of traditional kneading for high-hydration doughs. If genuinely too wet, add flour 1 tablespoon at a time.

12. Scoring Didn't Open ("Ear" Didn't Form)

🔍 You scored the bread but the cuts sealed shut during baking instead of blooming open.

Cause 1: Blade wasn't sharp enough or the cut wasn't deep/angled enough.

Cause 2: Over-proofed dough has no oven spring left — the scoring has nothing to push it open.

Cause 3: No steam — the crust set before the bread could expand.

✅ Fix: Use a razor blade (lame) and cut at a 30° angle, about 1cm deep. Score bread that is properly proofed (not over). Ensure adequate steam in the oven for the first 15 minutes of baking.

The 5 Golden Rules

Weigh everything. Volume measurements are unreliable for bread.
Trust time. Longer, slower rises produce better bread.
Control temperature. Dough temperature, water temperature, room temperature, oven temperature — they all matter.
Don't add extra flour. Wet dough is almost always correct. Resist the urge.
Wait before cutting. Patience after baking is the hardest part, and the most important.

Why Did My Bread Fail? 12 Common Problems Solved